Virginity Test? Throw Back to 18th Century: HRD Minister - Instablogs
Virginity Test? Throw Back to 18th Century: HRD Minister
Shafee Ahmed.Ko , Chennai: Jul 14 2009
Made Popular Jul 15 2009
India :

Virginity Test? Throw Back to 18th Century: HRD Minister

The mass weddings are quite common as part of the social work either through NGOs or through State government sponsored one. As per the reports from the dailies, last month a mass marriage comprising of 151 girls had been conducted in Madhya Pradesh on June 26. Nevertheless, this virtuous and morally excellent act in in the State, has turned into a vile aspersion; the reason being all the brides were reported to undergo virginity test before the wedlock.

In Rajya Sabha, on 13th. June this has ‘evoked strong condemnation from non-BJP parties even Chief Minister Shivraj Sing Chouhan denied such tests were carried out’. All that the Chief Minister Chouhan could accept was that such tests were part of routine for 151 girls; to be married under the ‘Mukhya Mantri Kanyadan Yojna’.

The mass wedding took place at Shadol, 600 km east of Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, on 26 June 2009. He said that it was ‘not a virginity test, just a procedural medical examination’. More shocking to the news were that alleging remarks that the tribal girls are subjected to undergo.

virginity test to be eligible for various government schemes. Union Human Resource Development Minister Kapil Sibal has come down heavily on the matter describing it as,’as shameful, an insult to women and a throw back to the 18th. Century’.

It might necessitate the department concerned to consider only the virgins should be married and non-confirming to virginity to be declined the courtesy of mass wedding. Practically speaking, even those who get normal marriages, never think of virginity at all. Has any man asked his would be wife, ‘Are you a virgin?’. Such ideas are utopian and are given to impractical schemes leading to imperfection of nuptial bliss.

Many marriages stand on quagmire pathetically unsound, broken on sheer qualms and fears on fidelity lacking mutual trust. Once married, the wife becomes the exclusive property of love, vis-à-vis with the husband. Many successful marriages are there even after failed romance, choosing a new partner. There are couples openly discussing about the past failed events. There are virgin boys marrying widowed girls; not necessarily a widower to marry a widow.

If the virginity test is to confirm whether the bride is pregnant, what good it has in the mass marriage?. Such tests hold no water.
Those who rule the nation should not play with the social liberty and rights of the people. It is better an unwed pregnant to get married soon than to be an unwed mother.

Let us not have virginity test either in mass marriage or in individual marriage. It is senseless.

“Love and marriage, love and marriage
Go together like horse and carriage
This I tell ya,brother,
You can’t have one without the other”

(Sammy Cahn-1913-93-“Love and Marriage”)

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
3 Stars
Trevor
San Francisco, United States
What about the virginity of men??
2 Stars
Garima
Nagpur, India
Backward thinking people can be found anywhere, be it politics, villages, shopping malls, pubs...every where. and he forgot to conduct those tests for men.
1 Stars
Swati
Amritsar, India
I fully support the MP government and Shiv Raj Singh Chauhan on this issue.
1 Stars
Elias
Bombay, India
i like what Kapil Sibbal said. And i have always observed him talking sense.
1 Stars
Trevor,
If a bachelor says that he is a bachelor, some times we have to think, how many percentage he is a bachelor!!!!
1 Stars
Elias,
Ya, He is worth of his word.
1 Stars
Garima,
Narrow mindedness is never to be mended.
1 Stars
Jas
Liverpool, United Kingdom
This is not backward thinking. It's in fact modern thinking. When you have scientific methods to check the virginity why not to go for it?
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Jamie
Birmingham, United Kingdom
This is not backward thinking. It's in fact modern thinking. When you have scientific methods to check the virginity why not to go for it?
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
There is no scientific method, and even if there were it is a degrading, humiliating, inhuman thing to do.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Swati,

Perhaps you may differ in opinion. There are no two opinions that the couples are chosen for ”Kanyadhan” must be virgin. In case of erratic romance, a haste pregnancy has occurred,as love is blind, should they be separated by unwanted laws? Even otherwise, if this couple is denied of opportunity of the ”Kanyadhan” marriage,the can marry as well elsewhere.
4 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
Testing for virginity just shows how ignorant the doctors are. REAL doctors know that there is no way to tell why a person does not have a hymen.

Many are born without one or only a small remnant of one. Strenuous activity can tear a hymen, so can tampons.

How many women throughout history have been murdered for not having bled enough to suit misogynistic, tribal, religious, backwoods savages? How many cultures required a viewing of the blood on wedding night sheets?

How humiliating! To be viewed as nothing more than property, like checking a horses teeth before you buy it! Or being viewed as damaged property, thereby being negotiated at a lower price like a dented refrigerator.

Exactly how long will it take before everyone accepts the fact that females are actually human beings and not cattle?
1 Stars
Nuya
Jas

For virginity test,no digital factor is required. As Nuya has rightly said,there is no question of hymen to be intact or ruptured. Nuya has given explanation on hymen rupture more than enough.

In this particular ”Kanyadan” marriage,what I do understand is,the government sponsored agents,perhaps made an effort to avoid pregnant woman for this marriage. If that would be the case,prior to marriage,they could have put a convenient ordered for urine test for positive pregnancy.

As I have already mentioned erstwhile here, what if a pregnant candidate happned to be a bride for the ”Kanyadan” marriage? Some who have been proved positive for pregnancy are reported to have been disqualified for the marriage. Think of the mental agony in such fiasco, a complete ignominious failure.
1 Stars
Capt.
New delhi, India
I have come to iknow that in some Community there is a tradition even now whern Blood stained bed sheet of wedding Night is shown in the Woman folk .that is why some female are going for a Surgery, it was reported in News papers.It mean that in 21 st centuary still people hold some tradition as their culture in India I had come across one case when a Doctor Husband left his wife as he declared her not vergin in 1970.
2 Stars
Sanwali
Shimla, India
This is an example for the most primitive mentality.
2 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
It is time to force people to grow up for their own good and the good of all mankind. Courts should tell people that they are being stupid and childish and tell them go away and not waste court time with their primitive foolishness. People have tried to bring such foolishness as someone accusing another of putting a curse on them, the judges say, Get out of my court with that ignorance or I will hold you in contempt of court! That is all it takes. There is no excuse for being that stupid in the 21st century when education and information are so easy to get.
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Capt
Sanwali

Hymen is a fold of mucous membrane just an envelop to the vagina. History of sexual intercourse cannot be determined either with presence or absence of the hymen. The reason for rupture is already dealt here.

The blood stain in the nuptial night may be considered as a folklore. Most maiden(first) conjugations are reported without blood stain,and it is no more an issue.

The great inhuman act conducted here in the particular ”Kanyadan” is deplorable.
It is an affront to the whole women in India. The rulers,elected through democratic norms cannot play with womenhood with their whims and fancies.
1 Stars
Capt.
New delhi, India
Sanwali
I have given my comments prevalant before this controvercy, that too through Media , Some people are perticular some are not , it has been reported all in the Media. I dont have practical knowledge about it so I feel sorry if some sentiments are hurt.
1 Stars
Nuya,
Rural India is full of myths and superstition,with irrational beliefs and ominous significance. Full of obsessed in cock and bull stories.
The pseudo or fake godmen or women exploit (gullibles) ignorance. You speak sense,you are sure to be labled as anti god. The enigma is quite intricate and needs massive scientific education.

Menstruating women are considered taboo and unclean to enter the holy places. It’s not considered as a natural outlet to flush out an unfertilized ovum(egg)from the uterus,same as the excretion of urine and fecal matter.
2 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
There is an Arabic saying, “man tamantaqa faqad tazandaqa” (he who uses logic becomes an atheist)

I don’t like the thought of people being exploited by unscrupulous people playing on their ignorance. Lack of proper education is a handicap. Biology, anatomy and human physiology education would go a long way in dispelling those irrational beliefs.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Anne Mary
New Delhi, India
Shafee,
You are more concerned with women’s subject.Bravo.
1 Stars
Mary,

Welcome.

Please keep writing.

There are intellectual giants here.
Please go through all topics.
Thanks.
1 Stars
veena
delhi, India
Shafee,there is a twist , some women who were already married just came to this function because of the money the govt was offering, it reuced the number of actual girls who could have benefitted from this .regarding virginity it is fast becoming a medievial age notion with at least all educated persons knowing the medical contention that hymen can rupture if a girl is a sports person ,so there.
1 Stars
Veena,
Please listen:
Question of rupture of hymen is not an adequate content of my conception.

Much has been discussed the rupturing of hymen. Whether the girl is sport prson or otherwise,hymen is likely to be ruptured even in normal day to day cycling. Hymen is absent congenitally too. How could a man doubt his newly married bride the very night of coitus,if unbled or unstained?
To know this simple matter one need not study the anatomy of the female pelvis.
Add your Comment